New Jersey congressmen on New York toll plan: Drop dead

Reporters gather around U.S. Rep. Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5), standing at podium, as he speaks during a news conference near the George Washington Bridge talking about the congressman's plan to fight back against New York City's proposed congestion tax on New Jersey commuters, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in Fort Lee, N.J. Gottheimer and Rep. Bill Pascrell (NJ-9) announced legislation they say will ensure New Jersey motorists, who already pay up to $15 for bridge or tunnel tolls, won't be charged twice. New York's legislature approved a conceptual plan this month. that will allocate revenue to fix the city's mass transit system. New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to reduce gridlock and fund mass transit improvements. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
A truck, left, travels westbound off the George Washington Bridge as commuters line up to cross a toll plaza, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in Fort Lee, N.J. U.S. Rep. Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5) and Rep. Bill Pascrell (NJ-9) held a news conference to announce they plan to fight back against New York City's proposed congestion tax on New Jersey commuters. The congressmen will propose legislation they say will ensure New Jersey motorists, who already pay up to $15 for bridge or tunnel tolls, won't be charged twice. New York's legislature approved a conceptual plan this month. that will allocate revenue to fix the city's mass transit system. New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to reduce gridlock and fund mass transit improvements. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
Vehicles bearing license plates from New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and Pennsylvania line up before at the George Washington Bridge toll plaza, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in Fort Lee, N.J. U.S. Rep. Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5) and Rep. Bill Pascrell (NJ-9) held a news conference to announce they plan to fight back against New York City's proposed congestion tax on New Jersey commuters. The congressmen will propose legislation they say will ensure New Jersey motorists, who already pay up to $15 for bridge or tunnel tolls, won't be charged twice. New York's legislature approved a conceptual plan this month. that will allocate revenue to fix the city's mass transit system. New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to reduce gridlock and fund mass transit improvements. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
U.S. Rep. Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5), left, and and Rep. Bill Pascrell (NJ-9) stand at a podium during a news conference near the George Washington Bridge talking about the congressmen's plan to fight back against New York City's proposed congestion tax on New Jersey commuters, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in Fort Lee, N.J. The congressmen announced legislation they say will ensure New Jersey motorists, who already pay up to $15 for bridge or tunnel tolls, won't be charged twice. New York's legislature approved a conceptual plan this month. that will allocate revenue to fix the city's mass transit system. New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to reduce gridlock and fund mass transit improvements. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
U.S. Rep. Bill Pascrell (NJ-9), right, stands with Rep. Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5), left, and and Fort Lee Mayor Mark Sokolich, back, during a news conference near the George Washington Bridge talking about the congressmen's plan to fight back against New York City's proposed congestion tax on New Jersey commuters, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in Fort Lee, N.J. The congressmen announced legislation they say will ensure New Jersey motorists, who already pay up to $15 for bridge or tunnel tolls, won't be charged twice. New York's legislature approved a conceptual plan this month. that will allocate revenue to fix the city's mass transit system. New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to reduce gridlock and fund mass transit improvements. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
U.S. Rep. Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5), right, and and Rep. Bill Pascrell (NJ-9) talk about traffic on the George Washington Bridge following a news conference near the bridge talking about the congressmen's plan to fight back against New York City's proposed congestion tax on New Jersey commuters, Wednesday, April 17, 2019, in Fort Lee, N.J. The congressmen announced legislation they say will ensure New Jersey motorists, who already pay up to $15 for bridge or tunnel tolls, won't be charged twice. New York's legislature approved a conceptual plan this month. that will allocate revenue to fix the city's mass transit system. New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to reduce gridlock and fund mass transit improvements. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)

FORT LEE, N.J. — New York's plan to charge a fee for motorists entering its congested midtown area won't go into effect for another two years but is already renewing time-honored animosities between the state and its neighbor to the west.

Standing on a bridge overlooking the heavily traveled George Washington Bridge that connects the two states, two New Jersey congressmen on Wednesday variously called the plan "poorly conceived," ''a raw deal" and "a two-by-four to our head."

New York would become the first American city to use so-called congestion pricing to decrease vehicle traffic and fund mass transit improvements, following in the footsteps of London, Singapore and Stockholm. Those cities experienced an initial reduction in traffic and gained a steady revenue stream for public transit.

New York will use the revenue, estimated at up to $1 billion annually, to refurbish its aging and chronically underfunded subway system. The state legislature passed the fee plan this month, but details are far from being finalized.

In response, Democrats Josh Gottheimer and Bill Pascrell on Wednesday outlined legislation, to be introduced by Gottheimer and Republican New Jersey Rep. Chris Smith. The legislation would bar New York from getting some federal transportation grants if it doesn't exempt New Jersey motorists from the fee or, in addition, allow New Jersey residents to deduct the fee on their taxes.

Pascrell said they also sent a letter to Democratic New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo urging him to consider sharing some of the revenue for transit needs in New Jersey.

"Our taxpayers already contribute to the billions in federal transportation dollars that New York subways get every year," Gottheimer said. "Not to mention what many of our residents pay in New York income taxes and what we spend in New York restaurants and in their stores and on their shows. New York just can't come along and take an additional two-by-four to our head, just because they feel like it."

Motorists traveling from New Jersey pay up to $15, if they pay cash, to cross the George Washington Bridge or go through the Lincoln or Holland tunnels into New York. Since both tunnels empty out into the congestion zone, it's expected those commuters will receive a credit for the toll they're already paying.

The George Washington Bridge enters Manhattan further north, above the congestion zone, and motorists there likely won't receive a credit. That raises the specter of thousands of cars shifting from the bridge to the tunnels, both of which already are the site of daily gridlock.

At a separate event Wednesday, Cuomo said the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which operates the bridge and tunnels, should implement cashless tolling at those locations to enable that data to be read and an appropriate toll charged when a vehicle enters the congestion zone.

He also downplayed suggestions of an interstate feud.

"There is no New Jersey-New York tension," he said. "We're not calling out the militia, New York navy crossing the Hudson. We don't have a navy."

More than 190,000 cars per day entered New York via the three crossings in January, according to the most recent data compiled by the Port Authority.

Commuters who drive also could migrate to public transportation, but that risks placing further strain on New Jersey Transit, the state's problem-plagued rail system that Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy called "a national disgrace" before he took office last year.

Nat Bottigheimer, New Jersey Director for the Regional Plan Association, an urban research and advocacy organization, noted that the fee roll-out, if handled poorly, could have negative effects on drivers and public transit.

"But assuming New Jersey drivers who pay tolls to enter Manhattan are credited somehow for the tolls they pay on bridges and tunnels, New Jersey commuters — the vast majority of whom take bus or rail transit — will benefit from improvements made to MTA or from reduced auto congestion on bus routes across the river," he said in an email.

___

This version corrects to show that more than 190,000 cars enter Manhattan daily instead of 270,000, according to Port Authority statistics.

People also read these

Global stocks lower, except for Tokyo, on Yellen speech

Aug 29, 2016

Most global stocks slipped Monday on remarks from the U.S. Federal Reserve late last week that the case has strengthened for raising interest rates, but the Tokyo market was an exception and gained on prospects for a strong dollar

Police look into whether sun glare was factor in kayak crash

Aug 31, 2016

Authorities are looking into whether sun glare was a factor in an accident in which a ferry departing a New York City pier slammed into a group of kayakers, critically injuring one

Stocks rise as tepid jobs report stokes hopes for low rates

Sep 2, 2016

US stocks rise as a tepid jobs report for August convinces more investors that interest rates will stay low for longer

Walk The Biz welcomes all casual and easygoing readers who seeks to digest business travel to international trade policy to starting in the transportation & shipping industry.

Contact us: sales@walkthebiz.com

Subscribe to our newsletter now!

Name:

Email: